Trial Balance & General Ledger Transaction reports imbalance involving Billable Time

This is my first time using accounting software, so I’m still trying to figure out the ins and outs. I know the fundamentals of double entry accounting.

I’m using this to keep track of personal finances, so I’m attempting to input my hours worked and wages received from multiple income sources. However, I’m still getting a mismatch on the trial balance exactly equal to the amount of income, so I believe the issue is somewhere in the income workflow.

My current income workflow is as follows:

  • Create an entry in Billable Time for the amount of hours worked for the pay period.
  • Create a Sales Invoice for the gross amount of the pay stub and a single line item for “Billable time - invoiced” (the customer is assigned to the Wages Receivable control account, which is classified as an asset).
  • Create a Receipt for the gross amount of the pay stub, received in the bank account and with a single line item for Wages Receivable pointing to the appropriate Sales Invoice.
  • Create a Payment from the bank account with multiple line items representing each withholding, each line pointing to an expense account.

This seems to me like it should work, yet the trial balance is unbalanced and I’m not sure why (seems to be coming from the Retained Earnings account). Is there something missing or incorrect in the workflow? Do I need to use the Withholding Tax option instead?

Looking through the General Ledger Summary report and going through the transactions for the Retained Earnings account, it looks like there are debits in the amount of the Billable Time that total the exact amount the trial balance is off on the debit side. Could this be a bug with Billable Time? Or am I missing something with how Billable Time is supposed to work?

For added context, this is the Billable Time Summary:

Hello @Brianna,

Welcome to the forum.

Please share the following information:

  1. Screenshot of the trial balance report showing the header and totals.
  2. Edition & version number of Manager

Desktop edition of Manager. Version 26.6.17.3647

Here are the screenshots of the trial balance:

(Apparently, I can only have 1 embedded image per post. Will make second post.)

Note: Neither “Billable time” nor “Wages Receivable” appear on the trial balance at all.

Just updated to desktop version 26.7.6.3652, and the trial balance looks the same.

The difference in the Trial Balance report is 3,804.99.

The missing Billable Expenses account explains 3,800.04 and leaves 4.95 unexplained.

This could be a bug, but before escalating, I need to gather a bit more information:

  1. How much is the Wages Receivable account balance as of this trial balance date?

  2. A screenshot of the Edit screen of this Wages Receivable account

  3. A screenshot of the Edit screen of the Trial Balance in question.

Ok, I’ve gone ahead and made a test business to reproduce and isolate the issue. I have the .manager file, but I can’t upload it here. May I send it to you another way?

Also, I misspoke earlier. The difference is not the amount in Billable Time. It’s the total of all of the invoices based on that billable time.

In the test file, I have 2 billable time entries for $100 and $200. The invoices are $150 and $250, respectively. The trial balance is off by $400.

To answer your question, the Wages Receivable account balance is 0.

The wages receivable edit screen.

The trial balance edit screen

The trial balance itself:

Here’s the edit screen of one of the invoices. The other is set up similarly with a different amount total.

Aha! Looks like I can attach files now. Here’s the backup file for the test business. No personal information is in here.

Test Business.manager (80 KB)

I can see the issue here and it persists on current Cloud version.

I will note that:

  1. This does not affect Summary, Summary > Transactions or General Ledger Transactions reports

  2. This issue also affects General Ledger Summary report

The good news is that this is only a display issue of some reports and not an imbalance in the General Ledger, but it’s still a bug.

I will escalate this to bugs.

Update: I just figured out what is causing the bug. It’s related to using a control account for the Customer of the Sales Invoice. I was using the Wages Receivable control account, but if I remove that (using the base Accounts Receivable), then the Trial Balance and P&L both show the correct amounts.

It seems that using a Customer control account means that Manager no longer creates the “Billable time - invoiced” and “Billable time - movement” entries in the P&L, which means the Trial Balance is off.

That’s great detective work right there.

I’m sure this is going to help speed up the fix.